Read some of our rave reviews from our clients.

We would love to hear your story too!

“Rosie was amazing from start to finish. She promptly responded to my first inquiry and from there, the process was seamless. We set up an in-person tasting to chose flavors and talk details about my vision for the vibe I was going for. And she executed beautifully. The cake was gorgeous and everyone talked about how delicious it was. We did one tier of chocolate mocha chip with chocolate ganache and buttercream frosting as well as another tier of banana cake with peanut butter filling and buttercream frosting. For the vibe, I wanted something elegant, yet simple. I was open to different textures, however I wanted to stick with neutrals along with my dried florals. Let me just say – she nailed it” Submitted 11/28/23 by Amanda Garcia

Rosie was absolutely wonderful to work with to create the wedding cake of our dreams! We had a 1920s themed wedding and her creation far exceeded our expectations! We received so many compliments on the style of the cake! The cake not only looked stunning, but it was delicious! Thank you Rosie! Submitted 11/16/23 by Jenna Seesholtz

Rosie did an incredible job on our wedding cake. It was beautiful and delicious. Our guest loved every bite. I highly recommend for your wedding! Submitted 10/2/23 by Tammy Heck

Rosie knocked it out of the park with our cake! It was exactly what we asked for and even more delicious than I remembered. She accommodated us with a virtual tasting and was responsive throughout the whole planning process. We went back and forth after I made some changes and she still delivered the perfect product. I wish I had photos back to share but I couldn’t wait to post this review. Thank you, Rosie!!” Submitted 9/12/23 by Lindsay Ortwein

Rosie, Cheryl and I just returned from our weekend vacation which included our vow renewal at the PA Renaissance Faire. In short, the cake you created for us was PHENOMENAL!!!! Not only did it look amazing, but all of our guests were raving about how delicious it was. Thank you so much for such a wonderful creation and an unbelievably delicious cake. If you have a preferred website(s) that you prefer to have customers add their reviews, please let me know as I would be thrilled to write one for you. Submitted 9/4/23 by Michael & Cheryl Lafferty.

We were blownnnn away by the cake !!! I sobbed when I finally saw it last night . You are a creative genius and perfectly captured my entire vision . Thank you thank you thank you ! You absolutely nailed it , as I knew you would. This was my dream wedding, and you created a masterpiece . All my love and gratitude to you. Xoxox. Submitted 11/21/22 by Morgan Geduldig-LeDesma

Thank you so much for our wedding cake!! It was BEAUTIFUL and delicious! People had rave reviews of both flavors and it was just stunning on the farmhouse table!  Cannot wait to eat our anniversary cake and continue the memories. Submitted 10/19/22 by Sarah & Ryan Hart

Hi Rosie, we wanted to reach out and thank you and your staff for a beautiful cake. Everyone thought the leaves were real! It turned out so great and was definitely as unique as we are as a couple. Thank you so so much. Submitted 9/25/22 by Christy & Alex Hause.

We were very happy with how our wedding cake turned out. During the testing everything tasted great and we ultimately went with the bridal white. It was a big hit with our guests. Rosie was very helpful with the cake design and it turned out beautifully. I was so pleased when she had the idea to add lace detailing to our cake that was similar to the lace on my dress. It was the perfect extra touch. She even helped us with the perfect cake stand to match our style and venue. Highly recommend! Submitted 9/17/22 by Paige and Andrew Martin

We love Rosie!!! She was excellent at communicating with us and making our cake vision come to life. From the tasting to delivery, she was the best person to work with. The cake was delicious and all of our guests loved it! We loved having the option to have a wedding cake flavor and a separate flavor in the kitchen so our guests had choices. We cannot recommend her more! Submitted 8/17/22 by Molly & Joe Passmore

We were simply thrilled when we found Rosie’s cakes for our ceremony this year. We chose the Fiona, a white cake with white icing with strawberry filling, which Rosie decorated with flowers supplied by our florist. It was so gorgeous that I really didn’t want to cut into it. Our guests raved about the flavor, lightness and deliciousness of it. It had a hint of almond flavor, which was a hit, and the strawberries were fresh and tasty. I forgot to bring the leftover cake to a family event the following day and everyone was so disappointed! Rosie was responsive and easy to work with. She showed up right on time and built the most beautiful masterpiece. Thank you, Rosie. I highly recommend you to anyone! Submitted 6/29/22 by Cynthia Gorman

Finding Rosie’s Creative Cakes was such a blessing! From our first contact, Rosie was very supportive and super easy to work with. Being out of town was not any problem at all. Her cake was AMAZING! And her design was beautiful, and creative indeed! The peanut butter filling and mocha chip chocolate cake combo was so trasty! It was such a pleasure working with her. Blessings to you Rosie! Thank you for such a great cake that turned out to better than expected in all ways! Submitted 6/13/22 by Jewels Petrie

Rosie, Thank you so much for doing our cake so beautifully.  I couldn’t have envisioned a more beautiful cake for us, it was perfect! You were absolutely right about the flavor…it was the best cake (both of us) have had! Phenomenal job, thank you again. Submitted 10/25/21 by Jaszmin Toman-Hughs.

Rosie did a awesome job on our cake! We communicated through the pandemic over the phone and she still created the cake I wanted. It was beautiful and just as I imagined! The flavor was great also! Submitted 9/8/21 by Monique Medina

My husband and I were so impressed on how beautiful the cake came out. She brought my image to life!! The cake wasn’t  just beautiful it was also delicious and everyone raved about it! We can’t thank you enough. I was able to save and display my gum flowers for years to come. Thank you again.Submitted 8/17/21 by Sandy Han.

Rosie, I have been wanting to tell you how pleased we were with the palette design cake. It was not only gorgeous but absolutely delicious!! It was perfect for the occasion. Everyone raved about it!! My daughter and fiancé were thrilled with it. It made the celebration that more special. Thank you again for your artistic abilities!! We love your cakes.  Submitted 6/29/21by Robin Hartman

Rosie was so awesome to work with during our wedding process. Since we planned our wedding during Covid, she helped us to organize a cake tasting at home with small samples to go. The cake was not only beautiful but it was delicious. She was able to turn my vision into a reality. I would highly recommend using Rosie! Submitted by Lindsay Filling 6/14/21

We had such an incredible experience working with Rosie for our wedding cake! The entire process from cake tasting to wedding day was seamless and the cake was unbelievably delicious! We are counting down the days to eat the top tier!! Submitted 5/3/2021 by Liz Williams

Hi Rosie, Thank you SO much for making this absolutely beautiful cake for my mom’s 78th birthday.  The entire family loved it, and she said it was the best birthday cake she has ever had. You are a true pro, Submitted 4/26/21 by Tony Seyfert

Rosie, your creation was absolutely stunning.  We can’t thank you enough for capturing Emily and Dyllan’s wishes for the design of their cake.  Once we arrived at the Lancaster Country Club, more pictures were being taken of your cake than the bride and groom.  I am not exaggerating!  The cake was delicious and there were a few pieces that we were able to take home to enjoy today.  I will certainly share our very positive experience with our friends. All my best, Submitted 10/31/20 by Deb Saporetti

Our wedding cake made by Rosie was SO delicious and beautiful! We got the pumpkin spice flavor and our guests have been raving about the cake even weeks after the wedding. From the cake tasting, to emails, to delivering/setting up the cake, Rosie was so pleasant to work with and designed the cake exactly as I had imagined it 🙂 Submitted 10/17/20 by Terilyn Lahey

Our original baker dropped out and we were scrambling to find a new cake baker for our wedding about 2 months out. Rosie made the entire process so easy & the cakes were absolutely DELICIOUS! Guests raved & gave endless compliments on how gorgeous the cake was. We are so grateful for Rosie and are counting down the days to our first anniversary to get another taste! submitted by Samantha Cox 9/28/20

ROSIE YOU ARE AMAZING!!! oh my goodness, my mom opened that cake for me to see when she got back with it, and I literally started crying! I am STILL so beyond pleased with my order from you, I almost can’t put it into words. THANK YOU SO MUCH, I really just cannot thank you enough. I am absolutely amazed at how exact you got that cake to the picture that I sent you, you do incredible work. everyone loved it and it was delicious, it was definitely the main centerpiece of the party!! thank you so much again, I will be ordering from you again in the future for sure, and will be recommending you to everyone!!! and thank you so much for the smash cake upgrade, it was unexpected but entirely appreciated! I sent you a few pictures of how much Jaxon enjoyed his first cake  we hope you have an awesome holiday season! Submitted 12/15/19 by Jamie Howard

We loved working with Rosie! Her cakes were delicious and all the guests thought so too! We had so much fun going to the bakery and tasting all the fun flavors before our big day! The cakes came out exactly how we asked and we did not have any issues throughout the whole process. If you want a smooth sailing cake vendor experience go see Rosie… Submitted 11/6/19 by Ciarra Dasilva